When a new planner leaves, firm owners often assume compensation was the only problem. Sometimes it can be, but as I have shared for many years, it is much more likely a symptom of a larger problem that gives someone the push to leave a situation that has been frustrating them for months.
New planners want to contribute, develop their skills, and build a career. When your firm makes those goals unnecessarily difficult or at least perceived as unattainable, they eventually look elsewhere. Here are three common reasons they leave (besides compensation) and suggestions for how to better retain them (besides just offering more compensation!).
Lack of Support
Gaining new clients and growing AUM and revenue is exciting, but every new relationship creates work: gathering documents, entering data, researching strategies, preparing draft financial plans, scheduling meetings, and implementation. If you keep adding clients without adding staff, the existing team absorbs the work.
Frequently, it is the planner you hired several years ago who is ready for more responsibility. That person may now be capable of leading meetings and managing relationships, yet still spends much of the week chasing statements, completing service tasks, and updating planning software. They are expected to develop as an advisor while continuing to handle everything they did when they started. Eventually, “we need you to keep helping here” begins to sound like “your career can wait.”
What you can do: Review who is doing what across your team. Could an associate planner or perhaps some of your AI tools take responsibility for data entry, initial analysis, and draft plans? Could hiring an admin, CSA, or outsourcing be a solution to create capacity for your associate advisor to move up? Hiring support creates room for existing employees to advance.
If your growth strategy depends on everyone continually absorbing more work, expect retention problems.
This past week, at the FPA Summit Conference, a partner with 15 years of experience in a $2B AUM firm was lamenting how she was spending too much of her time dealing with items that should be delegated to associate financial planners, which don't exist in her firm due to the other partners’ reluctance to hire them.
Process Inconsistencies
Supporting multiple senior planners can provide valuable exposure in a new planner's career development. It can also become exhausting when each person insists on a different process. The requests span the entire spectrum from detailed analysis to five bullet points, all assumptions listed versus no assumptions listed, different charts and graphs, etc. Some differences reflect legitimate client needs. Others are personal preferences that have become unwritten rules that are inefficient.
The new planner ends up learning several versions of the same job, switching between them, and getting corrected for failing to remember who wants what. Competing deadlines make the situation worse, especially when every senior planner considers their request the priority.
What you can do: Establish common standards for meeting preparation, financial plan drafts, documentation, and follow-up. Identify where flexibility matters and where consistency would save everyone time. Also, designate someone to resolve competing priorities. Your newest employee should not have to negotiate workload disputes between the owners.
Client Service Compromises
During the interview, you promised mentoring, regular feedback, and opportunities to participate in client meetings. Six months later, mentoring sessions keep getting canceled, feedback only comes after mistakes, and the planner is still waiting for meaningful client exposure. Team members will notice the gap.
They also notice when the same pattern affects clients. One new planner shared with us recently how the advisor they support is unprepared for client meetings, does not know the situation as they should, tends to give the wrong advice, and makes promises that are not delivered upon. This puts the other team members in a tough spot since they may be left reminding the advisor, managing the client’s expectations, or apologizing for something outside their control.
Occasional mistakes happen. Repeated broken commitments raise questions about leadership, professional standards, and whether the firm operates according to its stated values.
What you can do: Make fewer promises and track the ones you make. Protect mentoring time, assign owners and deadlines to client commitments, and acknowledge missed expectations promptly. Better yet, bring the newer planner into your meetings so that they can capture and follow up on all of the items you promised.
Your employees learn what your firm values by watching what you consistently do. Before assuming a departing planner lacked loyalty and it was all their fault, examine the environment you created. Adequate support, consistent expectations, and dependable leadership give talented people compelling reasons to stay. Retention starts with making your firm a place where they can succeed.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Contact us at info@newplannerrecruiting.com if you have any questions or don't hire very often and would like us to help with your next financial planner hire.
Caleb and the New Planner Recruiting Team*
*AI-assisted

Leave a Reply